Tuesday, July 12, 2011

We Practice “Sitting” as God’s Subversive Counter-Revolutionary People (3): Eph.2:11-22



Eph.2:11-22

          As we “sit” under the cascading outpouring of God’s grace and goodness as narrated by Paul we come to realize how lavishly God loves us.  Such love as displayed in chs.1-2 of Ephesians is what alone catalyzes white-hot faith in us and consolidates it into an ongoing commitment to God’s great subversive counter-revolutionary movement against the revolution of sin against God and its outworkings in the attitudes, practices, institutions, and policies in the world.  These latter define for us what it means to be “human” and live “humanely” in this fallen world of ours.  God’s subversive counter-revolutionary movement (aka “church”) contests these definitions, unmasks their inhumanity and violence, and models God’s truly human way of living.  We must be thoroughly saturated and soaked in God’s way and will for us and gifts and graces to us to be effective agents of his counter-revolution.  Thus we continue to “sit” and in wonder and gratitude take in what God has done for and given to us.

          My remarks here will cluster around two central themes of this section:  peace and temple.

1.    Remember, peace is ours as gift to be maintained not a goal to strive for.

Paul’s ethic is, as we have seen, rooted in a “become what you already are” pattern.  Thomas Merton captures this when he writes:  “We are already one. But we imagine that we are not. And what we have to recover is our original unity. What we have to be is what we are”.[1]  Paul will later exhort his readers to “maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace” (4:3).  We are gifted with peace, who is Christ himself (2:14).  This unattainable grace is given to us; we have only to maintain it, not create it.  This is a precious learning in times of strife and conflict (which will surely beset us from time to time).

2.    Peace is the English translation of the Greek word which translates the great Hebrew word “Shalom”.  “Shalom” however, means much more than absence of conflict.  It points to God’s dream for a world of abundance, generosity, and wellbeing for all on every level of life.  Given that this “Shalom” is God’s gift to us in Christ, how might we “maintain” it as Paul exhorts?  
Here are some images to stimulate your imagination.  Which appeal most to you?  Which do you find most challenging?  We might, for instance,

·         Scatter shalom – as in seeds; small packets of reproductive potential; dried parcels of life
·         Raise shalom – as with children; think of mothers throughout all times and places in history
·         Nurture / cultivate shalom – like a gardener tending seedlings, a farmer growing a crop, or any of us caring for our house plants
·         Kindle shalom – as a fire: it sparks, burns, catches, consumes; alive and too hot to touch
·         Act out shalom – like a drama or a protest; action/praxis; from rehearsal to proclamation
·         Tell / testify / witness to shalom – telling stories of what we have seen and heard; shout and sing of what we have experienced
·         Celebrate shalom – with eagerness, joy, gratitude, wanting to share, re-minding ourselves and others that it’s life-giving and inviting
·         Desire shalom – so it becomes the thing we want more than anything else
·         Yearn for shalom – longing & hope; lament & aspiration, fervent prayer and striving
·         Work for shalom – effort, toil, struggle, “a long obedience in the same direction” (Eugene Peterson)
·         Practice shalom – patient, persistent, repeated behaviours; dedication because you don’t usually get it right the first time (or any time)
·         Experience shalom – with humility, because we too need to find wholeness and healing for our own brokenness and wounds
·         Embrace shalom – like a hug that offers welcome, hospitality; arms entwined together
·         Struggle for shalom – vigorous engagement, perhaps even conflict; combat / challenge / try to overcome ignorance, hate, apathy, fear, self-righteousness, pride
·         Risk shalom – sacrifice, wager/gamble; never a sure thing, like the radical contingency of history that is still in the making
·         Think / study shalom – reflect, critique, examine, contemplate, analyze, strive to understand how it works and what helps it to flourish
·         Wait for shalom – never complete in our lifetime; it is ultimately God’s to create; will only fully come to fruition at the redemption of all creation
·         Seek shalom – like a treasure that has been lost; look for it, pay attention, watch very closely, discern in order to see what others can’t or won’t
·         Live shalom – be the change, make it integral to the way you live your life; be a living, breathing presence of shalom in the world
·         Imagine shalom – because we haven’t even begun to dream of all the possibilities, we need creative new ideas, transformed minds, and energized imaginations
·         Receive and share shalom – like a gift, given with the intent that it be passed along; a reminder that we can’t make it happen apart from God’s radical grace and generosity[2]

3.    Christ himself is our peace and transforms the cross into a peace-making instrument.

Yoder Neufeld offers wise words in this regard:
“In the first century, the cross had the same meaning that torture chambers,      firing squads, electric chairs, gas chambers, and lethal injections have for us     today.  Though early Christians might have heard of the emperor being called peacemaker, Caesar typically made ‘peace’ by putting his enemies (including    Jesus!) on the cross … The cosmic Peacemaker of our text dwarfs Caesar in        might and power (1:22).  But his way of dealing with hostile and unruly          subjects is to offer up his own life, his own body (members beware!), for the        sake of the reconciliation of humanity to each other and to God.”[3]

We might do well to mull this passage over several times before moving on.

4.    “Come to the Table”

I encouraged us to “Look to the Water” in the last section drawing on the baptismal imagery of that part of the letter (2:1-10).  Here, drawing on the imagery of Christ offering himself (as both priest and sacrifice) for us and our peace and unity – “in his flesh he has made both groups into one and has broken down the dividing wall . . . between us” (2:14) – I encourage us to reflect on and avail ourselves of the other great sacramental mystery – the Eucharist.  Thus, “Come to the Table”!

          The Eucharist is the great sacrament of the peace won for by Christ and given to us by God.  I don’t want to get into sacramental theology here.  But I do want to call attention to a practice you may or may not experience in your church’s celebration of the Eucharist but which may well prove vital and worth including in your Eucharistic celebration if it is not already there.  I refer to the practice of what we Presbyterians call “Passing the Peace of Christ” to one another.  It is often used in the Eucharistic liturgy.  Jason Goroncy draws on little-known history and offers such wise reflection that I will quote him at length here.

“So to return to the question with which we began: What does it mean to share Christ’s peace with each other? For many, the exchanging of the sign of peace can be embarrassing and awkward. We might offer a peck on the cheek to members of our family or to friends, but strangers are more likely to receive a distant nod or a polite handshake. But it was not always so.

“During the Middle Ages the kiss of peace was a solemn moment of reconciliation in which social conflicts were resolved. The community was restored to charity before Holy Communion could be received. One of the earliest preaching missions entrusted to the Dominicans and Franciscans was what was called ‘The Great Devotion’ of 1233. Northern Italian cities were torn apart by division which in some cases amounted to civil war. And the climax of the preaching was the ritual exchange of the kiss of peace between enemies. Here at the table – in the eating of one loaf and the drinking of one cup – was enacted the reconciliation made real in Christ.

“And here at the table, we confess that we Christians have often been unimpressive witnesses to Christ’s peace. Our history is marked by aggression, intolerance, rivalry and persecution. These days we usually avoid the extremes of some early Christians, rarely poisoning each other’s chalices or arranging ambushes of our opponents. But we still tend to succumb to the dominant ethos of our competitive and aggressive society, though rarely with the clarity of a First World War general who instructed his chaplain that he wanted a bloodthirsty sermon next Sunday ‘and would not have any texts from the New Testament’.

“I want to suggest that when we offer each other a sign of peace we are not so much making peace as we are accepting and confessing the Christ who is our peace. To be a member of the Church is to share Christ’s peace, however nervous or awkward we may feel. . .

“When we offer each other Christ’s peace we are doing no less than accepting the basis upon which we are gathered together. We recognise that we are here together not because we are friends or because we enjoy the chummy atmosphere, or because we have the same theological opinions, but because – and only because – we are one in Christ’s indestructible peace. That’s why we gather as church: to exchange the kiss of peace with strangers, to exchange the sign of our Lord’s victory in the face of all that assaults human community. . .

“When a French Dominican celebrated a family funeral after WWII he saw that the congregation was deeply divided. On one side of the aisle were those who had belonged to the Resistance and on the other those who had collaborated with the Nazis. He announced that the funeral Mass would not even begin until the kiss of peace had been exchanged. This was a wall that had to fall before it would have made any sense to pray together for the resurrection of their dead brother. Hanging onto alienation is mortal. It is, in the words of Ann Lamott, like drinking rat poison and then waiting for the rat to die.

“Jesus’ invitation to this table means his embrace of all the ways in which our communion is faulty, subverted or betrayed. Here, in bread and wine, he takes into his hands all our fear, betrayal, lies, cowardice, shame, pain, isolation, distances, silences, misunderstandings and disloyalties, saying, ‘This is my body, given for you’.

“Together we sing for joy that Christ comes, that he returns to our midst in the Eucharist, to strengthen us in our struggles, to share with us the burden of each day, to speak to us of peace when our minds are troubled, and to put the hope of eternal life in our hearts in that hour when our way seems to be entering the shadow of death. Here again we see that in spite of the barriers we have erected, the Eucharist is a sacrament of unity, joining us all in the same triumphant joy that the presence of the risen Lord gives to his Church. . .

“And so in this bread and wine, Christ is really present to us, even more present than we are to each other, more bodily. He is truly the embodied Word of God who pulls down every barrier. That’s what it means for him to say to us, ‘Peace be with you’. For him to be risen is, then, not just to be alive once more: it is to be the place of peace in whom we meet and are healed.”[4]

5.    We are the new temple, the dwelling place of God.
God resides in us, you and me!  Astonishing - even more astonishing than God deigning to dwell in the tabernacle and temple.  God present to the world in and through you and me.  This is the point of God’s subversive counter-revolution.  God dwelling in and with us on his new creation, glorified in and through us, his humanity, fully alive (as Irenaeus put it)!  Christ is gathering all things to himself (1:10) to order them in just this fashion.  This is God’s “eternal purpose,” that for which Christ died and God raised and exalted him “far above all rule and authority… and put all things under his feet” (1:21,22).  Think and pray on that and give glory to and worship God!


[1] Thomas Merton, The Asian Journal of Thomas Merton (ed. Patrick Hart, et al.; New York: New Directions Publishing, 1975), 308.
[2] Geoff Wichert at http://empireremixed.com/2011/06/08/vocabulary-of-shalom/#more-1009.
[3] Yoder Neufeld, Ephesians, 122.
[4] http://cruciality.wordpress.com/2009/07/24/christ-is-our-peace-a-reflection-on-ephesians-211%E2%80%9322/.

Ephesians 2 and Healing the Evangelism/Social Justice Divide



          A long-standing and well-known issue dividing American Protestantism throughout the 20th and even into the 21st century is the relation (or lack thereof) of evangelism (understood as the verbal announcement of Jesus’ death and resurrection for human salvation) and social justice (action directed to ameliorating human need and systemic injustice).  The continuum of views ranged from acceptance of one and rejection/ignoring of the other at either end of the spectrum, to asymmetrical relations weighted to the one of the other but acknowledging the legitimacy/necessity of the other, to a separate but equal relation between the two at the center.  We might picture it like this:

EVANGELISM------------EVANGELISM-----------EVANGELISM------------SOCIAL  JUSTICE-----------SOCIAL JUSTICE
                                   social justice             SOCIAL JUSTICE            evangelism

            This division is unbiblical and deeply troublesome for the integrity of the church’s life and witness.  The Bible offers a holistic picture of Christian life and witness that never separates or privileges one over the other.  In fact, Ephesians 2 is perhaps the clearest and most integrative of all the passages that deal with these two issues.

          Unfortunately, the book of Ephesians was a stepchild among the epistles attributed to Paul in the twentieth century.  Only the Catholics paid it substantial attention and then primarily because of its high view of the church.  Higher criticism not only denied Ephesians was or could be from Paul, but reflecting the individualistic character of western culture, further denigrated the letter by dubbing it “early catholic” because of its emphasis on the corporate church.  Conservative scholars fought for Pauline authorship but still failed to hear much of Ephesians because of its tendency to read the New Testament through the lens of the 16th century struggles between Roman Catholics and the nascent Protestants.  The long shadow of those dynamics enabled Protestants to hear Eph.2:1-10 as an affirmation of the Reformation battle cry “justification by faith” but the individualism noted above along with a rather pervasive anti-institutionalism effectively muted the central role of the church in the letter.  This started to change a bit in the late 20th century as “church” emerged as a central category in theology which helped lead to a revaluation of Ephesians in biblical studies.  In our century, Ephesians (whether or not from Paul’s hand) has finally come into light and into its own.  Some even suggest that Ephesians and not Romans is the letter containing the master template of the life of the church in the world (a suggestion I would myself support).

          So, we can now read Ephesians in the holistic and integrative way Paul (as the canonical name of its author) intended.  And when we read Ephesians 2 in this fashion, we find a way of relating evangelism and social justice as two sides of the one great act of God for human and cosmic salvation.  I want to attempt such a reading in the rest of this essay.

          Timothy Gombis[1] has advanced studies in Ephesians by detecting the presence of a “divine warfare pattern” as a key structural feature of the letter.  The elements of this pattern,[2] drawn from the Old Testament, are:

Kingship; Description of Conflict and Victory; Celebration; Victory Shout; Temple-Building; Blessing

Psalm 24 offers a good example:[3]
Kingship (v.1); Description of Conflict and Victory (v.2); Victory Shout (vv.7-10); Assertion of Kingship (vv.7-10); Activity in the Temple (vv.7-10); Celebration (vv.3-6)
           
We see this pattern in Ephesians 1:20-2:22:
Assertion of Christ’s Cosmic lordship (1:20-23); Description of victory over alienation of humanity to God (2:1-10); Description of victory over humanity alienated from each other (2:11-18); the Church as the New Temple; celebrating Christ’s victory[4] (2:19-22).

          It’s the second element, “Description of victory,” I want to focus on here.  Paul has carefully correlated these two descriptions in matching terms.  Each begins with a description of the “old state” in which his readers (both Gentile and Jew) were in (2:1-3/2:11-12), followed by an announcement of God’s decisive act of salvation (2:4-7/2:13-18)[5], and concluding with a declaration of the new state they are in now (2:8-10/2:19-22).

          In each section it is the event of the cross and the resurrection that effects God’s decisive act of salvation.  In the first section God through Christ has overcome the alienation between humanity and himself (the vertical dimension, if you will).  In the second section, through this same Christ God has defeated the forces of division and dehumanization (the horizontal dimension).  If one overlays the horizontal dimension on the vertical dimension an empty cross is formed, which symbol aptly sums up God’s one victory through Jesus’ death and resurrection in its double aspect.  This is the way I propose we read Eph.2:  as a twofold description of the one act of God’s decisive salvation.

          On this reading of Eph.2 salvation encompasses both dimensions; each is integral to it and inextricably bound up with the other.  Witness in word and deed to either dimension is witness to God’s saving work in Christ, which makes it evangelism.  Experience of God’s grace is at one and the same time reconciliation with God and with other human beings in the church.  The former entails decisive changes in our personal lives; the latter in our social, political, and economic lives.  Repentance toward God means turning toward others to forgive and be forgiven, to share and be shared with, to do justice to them and have them do the same for you.  To live into the reality of this “one new humanity” (2:14) is to overcome all that divides us from each other in any and every sphere of life.  As we tell the story of what God has done for humanity in Christ we at the same time are inviting others to come and see what God has done for humanity in Christ in this new community.   

          This brief overview of Eph.2 is decisive, I think, for overcoming a divide that never should have been. We ought never have been asked to choose between sharing the good news of the gospel with others or living the good news in the social, economic, and political realities of life.  The renaissance for Paul’s letter to the Ephesians gives us the opportunity and impetus to relearn the fullness of God’s gospel.  God has saved us by grace through faith and bound us together with each other in one new humanity.  Declaring the faith and living the faith each bear witness to God’s good news.  Every word of invitation to accept the new life God has for us and every act of justice, mercy, compassion, and reconciliation offered to one another is evangelical, that is, having the character of the gospel.  Both belong together, one does not have priority over the other and neither has its fullness as gospel without the other.  In terms of our original diagram, Eph.2 moves us to the middle of that continuum where Evangelism (word) and Social Justice (deed) are, so to speak, the right and left hands of God’s new humanity, the church, where we find the lives God intended for us (2:10) and live together as God’s new temple, the place where God meets the 
world in healing embrace (2:21,22)!

          What God has put together, let us not keep putting asunder!


[1] Timothy G. Gombis, The Drama of Ephesians:  Participating in the Triumph of God (Downers Grove, IL:  InterVarsity Press, 2010).


[2] Gombis, The Drama of Ephesians, 28.
[3] The elements do not have to strictly follow the order of the ideal pattern.
[4] Gombis, Drama of Ephesians, 87-88.
[5] Note the corresponding “but” and “but now” in 2:4 and 2:14.

Saturday, July 9, 2011

Ephesians 2:19-22


2:19-22
These final verses of Ephesians 2 serve as the final element of the Divine Warfare pattern we have noticed and bring to a climax the double victory of God Paul wants us to remember.  Paul announces the reversal of status the Gentiles (“you,” v.19) have received through Christ – “no longer strangers and aliens” but rather now “citizens with the saints and also members of the household of God.”  A new people and a new family – the climax and fulfillment of God’s ancient promise to Abraham and through him the whole world.  Jews and Gentiles together under God’s rule and fatherhood; this is the world God dreamed forth in the first place.  Now in Christ, through his cross and resurrection, that dream has been achieved.  It now remains for this people, this family, to implement that victory as they move through the world as God’s subversive counter-revolutionary people.

This new people, this new family, has a foundation and a cornerstone (v.20).  In this construction imagery the “apostles and prophets”[1] of the church constitute its foundation.  Their witness, teaching, and life are unique and fundamental to the church’s identity and character.  Yet even more basic and structurally necessary is the “cornerstone”.  Snodgrass explains the significance of this image: 

“Cornerstones in ancient buildings were the primary load-bearing stones that determined the lines of the building . . . But the cornerstone image gained an importance far beyond its architectural connotations. Isaiah 28:16[2] was significant because it promised security in a time of destruction. Even if a flood came and washed everything away the cornerstone provided a place of refuge.[3]

Paul leaves us, then, with this schematic:
                   Cornerstone:  Jesus Christ
                   Foundation:  Apostles and Prophets
                   Superstructure:  Church members


Perhaps under the influence of this construction imagery, Paul moves on to another image to describe his people:  the temple.  In light of Paul’s consistent use of the “temple” to describe God’s people (1 Cor. 3:9b-11, 16, 17; 6:19-20; 2 Cor.6:16), and in light of Jesus’ clear affirmation that he was now God’s “temple” (John 2:19-22), this usage is rather more than an image – it is a description of reality.  Jesus and his people are now the temple – the place of God’s presence and glory, the place where earth and heaven come together, where humanity meets God and where God enters into his creation.[4]
      
    As earlier in this chapter (2:5-6), Paul uses another series of three words with the preposition sun (“together with”).  Here we find “fellow citizen” (v.19), “joined together” (v.21), “build together” (v.22).  Whereas the first set of these three sun-words stressed our unity with Christ in his resurrection and victory, this present set of three sun-words stresses our unity with each other as God’s people.

The temple was always meant to be, as Jesus put it, “a house of prayer for all the nations” (Mk.11:17).  Yet this purpose was continually frustrated by Israel’s disobedience.  The temple became a bastion of Israelite nationalism and exclusivism which ultimately brought down God’s judgment upon it.  The new temple which is and is in Jesus is everything that God intended the temple to be:  a multicultural community of praise and practice of the presence of God built on Jesus Christ.  The radicality of this claim and Paul’s making it is evident when we remember that it is just around the time of this letter that Jews and Syrians in Caesarea were slaughtering each other and that no one else held a view of such a multicultural temple.[5]

The last two verses both began with “in him,” that is, Christ.  In v.21 “the whole structure” of this new temple is “built together” (Jews and Gentiles united).  In a characteristic switch of metaphors Paul tells us that this building “grows” into the new temple of God.  Likely this switch of metaphors is occasioned by Paul’s desire to assert that this temple both is as an act of God in Christ (“built together” by God) and at the same time is becoming (“grows”) as a living organism what it already is.[6]  This is consistent with Paul’s overall approach with is framed by just this “already – not yet”/”become what you already are” view of Christian existence.

“In him,” Paul assures the Gentiles “you” are being joined to the Jews into a “dwelling place for God.”  This is the work of God the Holy Spirit.  The phrase here could mean “in spirit” or “spiritually” (as in the NRSV).  However, the parallelism of this phrase with “in the Lord” (v.21) and the two “in him” (Christ) phrases (vv.21-22) along with Paul’s evident Trinitarian view of the person and work of God that we have already noticed makes me think he is speaking here of the work of the Holy Spirit in building the new temple.[7]

In the beginning God placed Adam and Eve in a garden where he “walked and talked” with them.  What does the Bible call the place where God speaks and meets with his people?  The temple!

God appointed our first parents protectors and nurturers of this garden which he intended them to spread to all the rest of the then uninhabited creation.  That means the entire earth was to become a “temple” filled with presence of God and communion of his people with him.  After humanity fell into sin and God called Abraham and Sarah, a new Adam and Eve, to carry out his plan to reclaim and restore his creatures and creation.  From their family came the people God rescued out of Egypt in the Exodus.  God was present to this people in their journeying in the wilderness and their settling in the land of promise in, first, the Tabernacle (a mobile tent of worship) and, then, the temple in Jerusalem. 

The failure of Israel and its temple to prove faithful mediators or God’s presence and blessing to the world brought divine judgment on both.  That judgment, however, in the person of Jesus Christ, the one faithful Israelite, brought not only the end and destruction of the temple in Jerusalem, but, as Paul says here in Ephesians 2, laid the “cornerstone” of the new temple of God by his death and resurrection.  This new temple, however, is and is in a person, the risen and triumphant Christ.  He is now the “place” where God and humanity meet and commune.  And his people, who are “in him,” are part of this new temple as well.

As this Christ-Temple movement spread throughout the world of the 1st century and the wider world throughout the centuries since, the temple of God has extended its boundaries and extent.  In the end, according to John the Seer in Revelation, this complete and perfect people of God will come down from heaven as a city, the New Jerusalem.  This is a peculiar city however.  Its shape as a cube matches only one other space in the Bible – the Holy of Holies, the innermost and most sacred part of the temple.  John is telling us that redeemed humanity will be a “Holy of Holies,” a place of intimate and unbroken  communication, communion, and community with God.  And since this city covers the whole of the new creation, God’s dream to have a world full of his glory and presence is realized.  The whole earth has become the temple of the Lord.

There is no temple in the New Jerusalem (Rev.21:22).  The city itself is the temple.    And we – Jews and Gentiles together in Christ – are, and are growing into, this very temple in which God will dwell with his people in his new creation. 

Thus Paul displays the grounds on which we who have come to faith – white-hot passion for and conviction of the Lordship of Christ – ought to channel that conviction into a long-term commitment to the cause of God’s subversive counter-revolutionary movement.

Paul refers to Psalm 110:1 to indicate Jesus’ victory over all God’s enemies in his theme statement in 1:22.  In the Divine Warfare pattern the final element is the victor’s celebration at the temple.  Paul fills out this pattern by closing his narration of God’s decisive victories, or better, his one two-sided victory over sin and death in relation to God on the one hand, and over social division and destructiveness on the other by ending up at the temple.  Only this time, the temple is, as we have seen, not a material structure to which people come but rather a human organism in which one lives. 

And this human temple in which God now dwells in the Spirit is the evidence and offer of salvation to the world.  Thus, Gombis is justified when he claims:

“All of this points to how important it is that the church truly embodies the            life of God on earth.  The church must be faithful to its call because it stands          as the monument to the triumph of God over Satan and the powers of evil.              If the church does not faithfully embody God’s love in Christ, then God’s           victory is diminished.  We must celebrate our new identifies, walking in good      deeds rather than in patterns that formerly enslaved us.  And we must cultivate communities of restoration and reconciliation where there has been alienation, bitterness, and division.  These sorts of pursuits are not merely to be part of our doctrinal statements or our official documents but must be our urgent priorities.”[8]


[1] Paul’s placing of prophets after apostles suggests he has the prophets of the early church rather than Old Testament prophets in mind.
[2]A key Old Testament text that was surely in Paul’s mind in using this kind of imagery (see 1 Pet.2:6).
[3] Snodgrass, Ephesians, 138-39.
[4] See Nicholas Perrin, Jesus the Temple (Grand Rapids, MI:  Baker Academic, 2010).
[5] Keener, Craig S.  The IVP Bible Background Commentary New Testament (Downers Grove, IL:  InterVarsity Academic, 1994)
[6] This means growth in both the numbers and the character of this new temple.
[7] The lack of a definite article, that is no “the” in front of “spirit,” is no barrier to this view.  Definite nouns frequently occur without the definite article.
[8] Gombis, The Drama of Ephesians, 106.